202
The Self-Defeating Fantasy
youthful auditor, when he hears the vampires first descrip-
tion of drinking away someone elses life, says, It sounds
as if it was like being in love. The vampires eyes gleamed.
Thats correct. It is like love, he smiled (pg. 31). [12] But,
of course, it is a love without procreation. Immortality, for
the angels, for the devils, and for the creatures of modern sci-
ence, is a childless state, and to that extent a denial of human
potential and of human happiness.
Freud, in Beyond the Pleasure Principle [13], suggested that
we have adopted [
] the hypothesis that all living substance
is bound to die from internal causes [
] because there is
some comfort in it, meaning that all our own failures and
our own ultimate demise seem less terrible if seen as either
comparatively small or as inevitable. He goes on to assert that
The notion of natural death is quite foreign to primitive
races; they attribute every death that occurs among them to
the influence of an enemy or of an evil spirit. Freud does not
seem to recognize that our seeking of fatal causes heart fail-
ure, cancer, gunshot reflects no different motive. Instead, in
the spirit of Victor Frankenstein, Freud expresses admiration
at the writings of August Weismann
who introduced the division of living substance into
mortal and immortal parts. The mortal part is the body
in the narrower sense the soma which alone is sub-
ject to natural death. The germ-cells, on the other hand,
are potentially immortal, in so far as they are able, under
certain favorable conditions, to develop into a new indi-
vidual, or, in other words, to surround themselves with
a new soma. [13, pg. 616617]
This is an amazing statement. First, Freuds utter silence
here about earlier divisions of the living substance into body
and soul reveals a powerful scholarly blindness which can be
motivated, one supposes, only by a desperate need to believe